Critical analysis of research article

Critical Analysis of Research Article

This understanding research paper aims to critically examine the article titled “What predicts positive life events that influence the course of depression? A longitudinal examination of gratitude and meaning in life” by Disabato, Kashdan, Short, and Jarden (2017). The influence of appreciation and purpose in life on the development of depression is examined in this paper. The study evaluated the possible mediating function of thankfulness and a sense of purpose in the link between the indicators of good life experiences in adults with depression. It examined the determinants of such occurrences using a longitudinal methodology.

Purpose and Research Questions

The purpose of this research is to identify factors that increase the likelihood that depressed people will experience happy life occurrences and to determine the extent to which thankfulness and a sense of purpose mediate the link between such factors and positive life occurrences. The research question is clearly stated and the aims of the study are well defined according to Jordan & Zanna (1999). The study’s research questions are intended to respond to the research problem. The first research question aims to identify what factors may contribute to the occurrence of positive life experiences in individuals with depression (Disabato et al., 2017). The second research question investigates whether “gratitude and meaning in life” may mediate the link between these predictors and positive life events in individuals with depression.

Method

The researchers used a longitudinal design to examine the predictors of positive life experiences in people with depression and to assess the forecasted mediating role of “gratitude and meaning in life” in the link between these predictors and positive life events. The sample size is adequately described and appears to be appropriate for the research question according to Jordan & Zanna (1999). The sample consisted of 174 participants with a major depressive disorder recruited through a depression clinic and an online platform (Disabato et al., 2017). The participants completed measures of depression, positive life events, gratitude, and meaning in life at four-time points over six months. The measures used in the study are valid and reliable (Jordan & Zanna, 1999). The researchers used hierarchical linear modeling to analyze the data.

One study limitation is the sample size, which may not represent the general population. Additionally, the sample consisted mainly of White individuals, which may limit the generalizability of the findings to other racial and ethnic groups. Another limitation is the use of self-report measures, which may be subject to bias and may not accurately reflect the actual level of “gratitude and meaning in life” in the participants.

Results

The study found that social connectedness, positive affect, and perceived control were significant predictors of positive life events. Strong social connections and a positive outlook are essential factors in experiencing positive life experiences (Disabato et al., 2017). Perceived control, or the belief that one has agency and can influence events in their life, also plays a role in positive life experiences. Additionally, “gratitude and meaning in life” partially mediate between social connectedness and positive life events and between positive affect and positive life occurrences (Disabato et al., 2017). “Gratitude and meaning in life” seem to indirectly affect positive life occurrences, as they partially mediate the relationship between other factors (such as social connectedness and positive affect) and positive life events. However, ‘gratitude and meaning in life” did not directly forecast positive life occurrences. This aspect suggests that while cultivating gratitude and finding meaning in life can benefit overall well-being, they may not directly lead to positive life events.

Discussion of Findings

The authors discussed the findings in the context of previous research on the role of “gratitude and meaning in life” in depression. They argued that their findings support the idea that “gratitude and meaning in life” may be essential factors in the course of depression (Disabato et al., 2017). They partially mediated the relationship between social connectedness, positive affect, perceived control, and positive life events in individuals with depression.

However, there are possible alternative explanations for the findings. For example, it is possible that “gratitude and meaning in life” may not directly predict positive life experiences but may be influenced by other factors that do pr


Place your order